Explore intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation in schools, their benefits, & striking a balance for effective learning.
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
Jordan resides in Lexington, Kentucky. He has experience in Public Education as an Administrator, Science Teacher, and as a Coach. He has extensive experience with School Discipline, PBIS, SEL, Restorative Practices, MTSS, and Trauma-Informed Care.
“Students should do the right thing because it’s the right thing.”
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
“Students should do the right thing because it’s the right thing.”
That is a quote I hear from teachers all the time. It’s not wrong. Our students should know right from wrong and act accordingly. But what if they don’t? Maybe they need a little incentive to encourage them to do the right thing.
That can and does work. Positive reinforcement has been shown to lead to positive results.
You might be saying “But Jordan, a school can’t operate if the only reason students behave is because they will receive something in return.” That’s correct, everything can’t be transactional with students.
The same can be said of adults. Teachers and school staff work for a paycheck and benefits. Those are incentives that attract new teachers to the field. But teachers aren’t effective in their jobs because they are focused solely on those things.
They are often intrinsically motivated by a desire to teach and to see their students succeed. But our schools wouldn’t be staffed for very long if we only relied upon the goodwill of teachers.
Motivation is a complex topic for adults; the same is true for students.
Let’s take a beat to examine the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation before discussing the benefits of both.
Intrinsic motivation is like that fire in your belly, pushing you to do something because it feels right and lights you up inside. It's all about doing things because you should do them, not expecting a gold star or a pat on the back.
Now, extrinsic motivation? That's more like the carrot dangling in front of you, tempting you to take action with promises of rewards or punishments.
Think of it this way: intrinsic motivation is like that friend who's always there for you, cheering you on because they genuinely want to see you succeed. Extrinsic motivation is more like a bonus at work for meeting a deadline.
Both have their time and place, but understanding the difference is key to nurturing that spark within students while also giving them just a little nudge when it's needed. It's about finding that sweet spot where passion meets purpose.
Balancing both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation can create a dynamic learning environment. Let’s take a look at the benefits of each individually:
Sustained Engagement: When students are intrinsically motivated, they're more likely to stay engaged with tasks or subjects over the long term because they find personal satisfaction in the process.
Deep Learning: Intrinsic motivation fosters a deeper understanding of concepts as students pursue knowledge out of genuine curiosity, leading them to pursue knowledge for knowledge's sake.
Self-Directed Learning: With intrinsic motivation driving them, students are more likely to take ownership of their learning, setting goals, seeking out resources, and exploring topics independently.
Goal Attainment: Extrinsic rewards provide clear targets for students to aim for, helping them stay focused and motivated to achieve desired outcomes such as good grades or recognition.
Behavioral Regulation: External incentives can help shape behavior and reinforce positive habits, encouraging students to exhibit desirable behaviors like completing assignments on time or participating in class discussions.
Increased Effort: The promise of rewards or the threat of consequences can inspire students to put in extra effort and persevere through challenges, leading to improved performance and outcomes.
Intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation is a great debate amongst educators today. Programs and initiatives like PBIS, SEL, and Restorative Practices are often at the center of the discussion.
As an educator with a great deal of experience with all of these, it feels like a bit of a copout to take this position but it is the one I believe to be correct. You need both.
Too much reliance on extrinsic rewards can overshadow intrinsic joy, turning learning into a “this for that” experience. Conversely, neglecting external incentives altogether overlooks opportunities to reinforce positive behaviors and goals.
To focus on one and disregard the other is the same as teaching without differentiation in your classroom. We need to meet students where they are and striking the right balance here is just another way we need to do so.
To do it right, educators can integrate both forms of motivation strategically. Cultivating intrinsic motivation involves sparking curiosity, fostering a sense of autonomy, and nurturing students' innate passions.
Encouraging exploration, providing meaningful challenges, and offering opportunities for self-directed learning can all fuel intrinsic motivation. Think of the “gradual release” approach to learning and teaching new content.
At the same time, extrinsic rewards can complement intrinsic motivation, providing external reinforcement for desired behaviors or achievements.
By aligning extrinsic incentives with intrinsic goals and values, educators can maintain students' intrinsic interests while leveraging external rewards to support progress and growth.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an environment where intrinsic motivation flourishes naturally, while extrinsic incentives serve as valuable tools in guiding and shaping learning experiences.
All the behavior resources you need to create the positive culture your school community deserves.
